{"n_apps":833267,"gap_today":3.534,"gap_published":-0.598,"gap_today_inv":2.937,"gap_published_inv":-0.74,"contrast":4.274,"contrast_ci":[3.333,5.283],"shapley_vintage":3.905,"shapley_vintage_ci":[3.243,4.627],"shapley_type":0.369,"shapley_type_ci":[-0.042,0.784],"shapley_type_p":0.0801,"vintage_all":4.132,"vintage_all_ci":[3.393,4.953],"vintage_inv":3.677,"vintage_inv_ci":[3.058,4.341],"null_all":0.343,"excess_all":3.79,"null_inv":0.332,"excess_inv":3.345,"excess_p":0.0001,"k1_beta":0.403,"k1_ci90":[0.155,0.652],"k1_band":1.387,"k1_base":13.87,"k1_n":821647,"k1_n_defined":821783,"k1_pair_beta":0.659,"k1_pair_ci90":[0.364,0.957],"k1_pair_band":0.965,"k1_pair_base":9.65,"grant_n":656961,"new_pairs_pub":2.85,"new_pairs_grant":12.28,"new_pairs_today":20.95,"share_at_grant":0.521,"k2b_beta":1.552,"k2b_ci95":[0.881,2.234],"k2b_band":0.906,"k2b_base":9.06,"k2b_n":611888,"k2b_holm_p":0.0007,"k2c_beta":-0.081,"k2c_ci95":[-0.436,0.216],"k2c_band":2.635,"k2c_n":180196,"k2c_p":0.5849,"spec_n":432,"spec_min":-6.456,"spec_max":14.423,"spec_median":-1.309,"spec_below":190,"spec_span":187,"spec_above":55,"verdict":"B","propositions":[{"id":"P1","name":"Vintage","claim":"With documents, outcome and construction rule fixed, a novelty measure built from the current record is more positively associated with the outcome than the same measure built from the record as published.","refuted_by":"a type-matched vintage difference below 1pp","tests":[{"id":"D0","label":"Support","estimate":4.132,"unit":"pp","ci":[3.393,4.953]},{"id":"K3a","label":"Support","estimate":3.535,"unit":"pp","ci":[2.961,4.141]}],"state":"supported"},{"id":"P2","name":"Outcome dependence","claim":"Revision of a record is related to what happened to that record and not merely later than it.","refuted_by":"in the aggregate, a vintage difference no larger than outcome-blind revision would produce; at the level of the record, an association between provably post-decision information and the decision inside the preregistered equivalence band","tests":[{"id":"EXC","label":"Support","estimate":3.79,"unit":"pp","ci":null},{"id":"K1","label":"Kill","estimate":0.403,"unit":"pp","ci":[0.155,0.652]},{"id":"K4","label":"Inconclusive","estimate":2.199,"unit":"pp","ci":[0.142,5.127]}],"state":"supported in the aggregate, not at the level of the record"},{"id":"P3","name":"Reconstruction","claim":"Part of the revision is related to what the field later made of the invention.","refuted_by":"revision that postdates a closed observation window and is unrelated to the later recognition of the individual record","tests":[{"id":"K2b","label":"Support","estimate":1.552,"unit":"pp per SD","ci":[0.881,2.234]},{"id":"K2c","label":"Kill","estimate":-0.081,"unit":"pp per SD","ci":[-0.436,0.216]}],"state":"supported in one channel only"}]}